2026 10 Blog 4 1024x768 1

5 Scary Ideas That Can Wreck Your Fundraising

Halloween is a time when we go out of our way to scare ourselves. If you’re a fundraiser, the scary part might be how close you are to the year-end rush. 

But I’m going to scare you even more with some questions and ideas I keep hearing. These things make my blood run cold every time I see them. And I see them a lot. These ideas keep coming back. Every year. Every board meeting. You’ll be minding your own business, doing the work that raises money, and like a zombie, one or more of them will crawl back to life, staggering toward you to eat your brain. 

Here they are. The five scariest questions in fundraising… 

1. “What’s the ROI of that?”

This may seem like a sensible question from someone who wants to understand what a project is going to accomplish. 

It isn’t. 

If you focus on ROI, you could be missing the whole point of fundraising, which is to raise net revenue for your cause. 

You can artificially inflate ROI by sacrificing net revenue. Just mail a small number of high-dollar, super-connected donors. Your ROI will go through the roof. But you’ll leave a lot of money on the table. And increase donor attrition, because you aren’t giving as many of them the opportunity to give. 

A high ROI may feel good. But it’s not what you’re trying to accomplish. 

Here’s the test. Ask yourself: would you rather have a program that raises $100,000 at a 10:1 ROI, or one that raises $500,000 at a 4:1 ROI? The answer should be obvious, but when the focus is on ROI instead of net revenue, you can easily miss that point. 

2. “Our old donors are dying off. We need to pivot to young donors.”

We call it “permanent involuntary lapsing.” Normal people call it death. 

Everyone eventually dies. And older people are more likely to die than younger people. (I didn’t need to Google that fact.) 

The thing is, older people are the foundation of fundraising. They’re also the walls and the roof. They are our best donors. Most loyal. Most connected. And by far the most likely to include us in their wills. 

It’s true that younger people are going to be around longer than older people. They’ll be here on Earth, but not at all likely to stay on your donor base. They just don’t stick around. And they’re even less likely to think about putting us in their will. 

This may seem counterintuitive, but a donor file that’s heavy on older people is a healthy file. If your file skews old, congratulations. You stand to maximize your revenue in the coming years as your donors keep giving – and some of them write you into their wills. 

If your file starts to skew young, that’s when you should worry. It probably means your older donors are leaving faster than you’re replacing them. 

Don’t pivot away from your best donors. Go find more of them. 

3. “Our brand is tired and out-dated. We need to re-brand.”

If you aren’t getting tired of the way your brand looks, you probably aren’t doing enough fundraising. 

You see your brand every day. You’ve seen it a thousand times. Your donors see it now and then … maybe a few times a year. And they aren’t focusing on every word and image the way you do. To them, it isn’t tired. It’s familiar. And familiar is what you want. 

Re-branding is far more likely to hurt revenue and drive away donors than to make things better. I’ve watched more re-brands than I care to remember. A few were fine. A lot more were disasters. Almost none were worth the money and time they cost. 

If you must fiddle with your brand, do it quietly. Evolve. Don’t revolutionize. 

And if a fancy branding agency shows up promising a “bold new visual identity” that will “reinvigorate donor engagement” — run, the other way. That’s the proposal that leads to years of career-stunting pain. 

4. “I showed it to my spouse, and…”

The last kind of advice we fundraisers need is the opinions of non-professionals. Even if they fit the donor demographic exactly. 

Using family members as unpaid consultants always goes badly. 

They are not fundraising experts. You’ve probably noticed that a lot of what we know about fundraising is counterintuitive. Your family member does not know that. All they have is their intuition about what they think should work. 

And the problem goes even deeper than that: Suppose your family member knows quite a lot about fundraising. Maybe you talk about it together. (That’s how it is at my house. Sorry, honey!) Nobody’s conscious beliefs about what they would respond to are anywhere close to what they would really respond to. Because what you think you’d respond to is not at all what you’d really respond to. They two things are miles apart. 

Real donors respond to things that most people would call “too long,” “too emotional,” or “kind of embarrassing.”  

This isn’t a freak occurrence that happens now and then. It happens constantly. When you get family member’s thoughts on fundraising, you automatically get destructive advice. 

Trust the data. Trust the results. Politely thank your spouse — and then send the letter you were going to send. 

5. “We haven’t explained how our programs really work. Let’s make sure people understand.”

Donors don’t give because they fully understand how your programs work. They give because they want the outcomes of those programs. 

Explaining drives down response. Every single time. 

Here’s something that happened to me:  

The Executive Director fumed at an appeal I’d written. 

“We need to be straight with our donors,” he said. “Show them these facts – not emotional pabulum.” 

The “pabulum” I’d written focused on an unemployed local man who’d lost everything. He was living on a diet of what he called “homeless mac and cheese” – a packet of ramen noodles with a handful of cheese puffs mixed in. The resulting orange stew is warm, fills you up, and tastes almost like real food. 

The executive director hated my letter because it zeroed in on one person, not the “real problem” of increasing homelessness. It wasted an entire paragraph on homeless mac and cheese – a meaningless distraction.  

He’d gone to the trouble of composing a letter to replace the one I’d written. It was one-page long (mine was four). It opened with an extensive quote from a study on homelessness, then went on to explain how their programs worked. It didn’t directly ask. It just sort of hinted. There was no P.S. (“That’s unprofessional,”he sniffed.) 

You can probably guess the rest. We mailed the executive director’s letter. It received the lowest response in the organization’s history. It was a devastating loss of revenue, so deep the organization had to let staff go and scale back their services. 

I wish this was unusual. You know it isn’t. You’ve probably experienced similar things. 

Don’t explain. Inspire. 

Tell donor’s about the problem. Show them how they can be part of the solution. Make them feel something. That’s what raises money — not a well-organised description of your service model. 

Those are my five scariest sentences. Together, they’re the stuff of nightmares. 

The good news? None of them are unbeatable. You just have to see them for what they are — bad ideas dressed up as common sense — and be ready with a better answer when they show up.  

Reach for the garlic. And get back to the work that actually raises money. 

Want to end your 2026 with a bang? Download our free guide, Your Calendar for Successful Year-End Fundraising. It gives you a suggested timeline to plan and execute year-end fundraising, especially focusing on December. It’ll give you clarity, confidence, and great results! 

Related Blog Posts:  

Author

  • Jeff Brooks

    Jeff Brooks is a Fundraisingologist at Moceanic. He has more than 30 years of experience in fundraising, and has worked as a writer and creative director on behalf of top nonprofits around the world, including CARE, St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Feeding America, and many others.

    View all posts
Previous Post
Your Donors Are Ready to Talk Bequests. Are You?
Next Post
The Secret to Standing Out on Giving Tuesday

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Fill out this field
Fill out this field
Please enter a valid email address.